The work speaks for itself.
Gameplay, commentary, analysis, engagement and presentation. Independent evaluation, with a reasoned score.
Gameplay Quality — 25
Control, purposeful decisions, challenge handling and understanding of game mechanics.
Voiceover & Commentary — 25
Audible human commentary, clarity, explanation, timing and narrative.
Research & Analysis — 25
Accurate context, grounded evidence, mechanic comparisons and original insight.
Audience Engagement — 20
Hook, pacing, storytelling and comprehensibility. Likes, views and follower counts are not confirmed inputs.
Technical Presentation — 5
Understandable audio, legible capture and coherent editing. Expensive equipment is not required.
Policy approval pending
Three equally weighted judges and criterion-order tie comparison are proposed for synthetic demonstrations only. Missing scores never count as zero. Exact unresolved ties require approved adjudication; no random or hidden rank assignment is used.